Corruption Busters 2012 Round-Up



Corruption Busters 2012 Round-Up

–    a summary of the highlights of the past year, in the Public Interest, of course.
–    the Corruption Busters 2012 Awards for extraordinary corruption in North Yorkshire.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Well readers, 2012 was a great year for the Corruption Busters.  We pursued the following investigations:

·    Senior Officer corruption in North Yorkshire Police.

·    Chief Police Officers expenses.

·    The Great Robert Gooodwill MP computer porn controversy.

·    Jane Kenyon’s failure to fully declare her interests.

·    Jane Kenyon’s mishandling of the Whitby Regatta Committee and Whitby Regatta Limited shambles, resulting in both organisations operating in parallel and the Regatta being a commercial venture – not a Registered Charity.

·    Double-dipping by fifteen Scarborough and North Yorkshire Councillors, including breaking it in the national press.

·    County Councillor Jane Kenyon’s allegations of forgery of official documents, ostensibly by her life partner Councillor Bill Miller.

·    The “Case of the Clergyman’s Widow”.

·    Live cross-examination of Councillor Tom Fox on BBC Radio York by Tim Thorne, in which Fox was caught out lying about his expenses.

·    Revealed that Councillor Thomas William ‘Bill Miller” and County Councillor Jane Kenyon were officers of a bankrupt company which they had not declared in their Register of Interests.

·    Tracked down Jimmy Savile’s activities in Scarborough and Whitby, and the cover-up by North Yorkshire Police into the same, as well as identifying premises in Whitby equipped with an instrument of torture.

·    The scandal of the ‘Mouseman Thompson’ oak pew – sold on eBay for £25.00; though worth closer to a £1,000.

·    The eBay sale of a dredger pump, which brought around £12,000 unused, having been bought by SBC for over £50,000.

·    Nigel continues chasing the whereabouts of valuable paintings, supposedly in the possession of SBC, but now listed as ‘missing’.

·    Double-dipping by Robert Goodwill MP.

·    Challenged the North Yorkshire Police Authority Accounts and revealed that Chair Jane Kenyon had been double-dipping by having a mobile phone she was not entitled to and had it paid for by the Police Authority instead of paying for it from the allowance provided to her for that purpose.

·    Councillor John Blackburn using stamps provided for his Council duties by the Council for Conservative Party Political purposes

·    Continuing investigation of the “Me Too!” Voucher Scheme of forgeries and frauds

Clearly all very irritating and embarrassing for those concerned above and, unsurprisingly, we have had a mixed reception

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In Scarborough and Whitby, the local press do not do investigative-journalism, the Monitoring Officers ignore complaints, as do the Police, and so it must have come as a great shock for Councillors to suddenly be under intense scrutiny by the Corruption Busters investigative-journalists, leading to national press criticism (including three Private Eye pieces in the last six months) and a great deal of interest from other political journalists.

Consequently, there has been a predictable kickback from people who resent being held accountable for their actions by the public for the first time.

·    Councillors Chatt and Haddington abused their Council e mail addresses to write personally offensive e mails to Tim Hicks.

·    County Councillor Jane Kenyon ordered the exclusion  by the Police of one of our correspondents from a public Police Authority meeting for asking questions that were inconvenient and embarrassing to her.

·    Double-dipping Councillor and Party switcher extraordinaire County Councillor Brian Simpson described the criticism of Councillors in the press as an “onslaught” – ignoring the fact that it reflects public opinion and legitimate criticism from a free press in a democratic society, rightly concerned about the correct application of the law and of Council policy, and that Leicestershire County Council has taken exactly the same line as us over the David Parson’s scandal.  Councillor Simpson’s comments were then used as an excuse to illegally ignore all further complaints, thereby placing himself and his fellow double dippers above public scrutiny or any form of public accountability – the only Councillors in the UK to adopt this lofty position.

·    County Councillor Jane Kenyon abused her position as Chair of the North Yorkshire Police Authority to make a harassment complaint about Tim Hicks to the Police falsely, alleging harassment.  Normally a harassment complaint would be dealt with by a Uniformed Constable; this one was dealt with by Senior Detective Ventura [pseudonym].  Result:  Tim was interviewed under caution by two highly experienced detectives at Fulford Road Police Station, York, at Jane Kenyon’s request, regarding Real Whitby articles, but Police could produce no evidence of any offence and Tim was released without charge.

·    Senior Detective Ventura also wrote to Tim Hicks, on North Yorkshire Police headed paper in her official capacity as a Police Officer, threatening him with civil action on behalf of unnamed third parties, alleging that his articles were ‘misleading’ and asking him to remove them, ignoring the fact that civil matters are not the concern of any Police Officer and Detective Ventura’s letter was therefore an abuse of authority. This was one of a series of empty threats of legal action for libel that we have received during the year. Tim declined to remove the articles from Real Whitby and, as usual, has heard nothing more from anyone; presumably because the complainants know that telling the truth is not libel.

We have variously been referred to as “cyber terrorists” and “internet trolls”, and falsely accused of criminal offences for exposing misconduct, in the public interest.

In response to all of the above we would quote the words of the Rt.Hon. Eric Pickles, Communities Minister, on freedom of the press:

·    “I think it is really massively important to ensure that we have freedom of press in this country. Something that characterises the British press is that it is good at exposing corruption and it is good at going to places where other press wouldn’t and I think it was Thomas Jefferson who said that for a free society to operate then the river of a free press had to flow without restriction. So I think that given that I think the press are looking towards finding ways, the end result of offering a good way in which people have got a legitimate complaint can find a resource, then that’s right.”

Hopefully Councillor Simpson, Councillor Kenyon, North Yorkshire Police and Monitoring Officers everywhere will all take note for 2013.

On the other hand, more positively, we have; covered a number of corruption stories in North Yorkshire; been in the national press three times, including attracting one of the two Private Eye 2012 Corruption Awards, for the double-dipping story – which we perceive to be in recognition of the quality of our investigative-journalism; and we have developed close liaison with a number of national and local papers.

Best of all, we have also been stopped in the street frequently and congratulated on our work, which is very gratifying.

Our articles are read beyond Whitby and Scarborough by Councils throughout England and Wales, as well as many local and national newspapers. Interestingly, we are also getting a number of Government, Educational and Police Forces in England and Wales routinely monitoring the site –particularly since our Jimmy Savile investigation evidence was referred to Operation Yewtree. One user at Newby Wiske (NYP Force Headquarters) is apparently logged on more or less permanently (thought to be the NYP Force Intelligence Bureau).

·    And we have forced SBC to change the way that Councillors’ Broadband is reimbursed, thereby preventing some Councillors from siphoning off thousands of pounds from their Councils over the next four-year term; arguably our best achievement of the year.

That brings me to the moment you have all been waiting for:

The Corruption Busters 2012 Awards, and a look forward to 2013.

awards

The Egon Ronay Gourmet Prize for the Best Free Meals for the Very Rich

GOLD :Eastern Paradise Curry House. Strongly commended by Knob Dylan [pseudonym], shown here enjoying an evening (one of many):

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The “Miss X” and Mary Millington Memorial Prize for the Best Sex Story

GOLD : - Robert Goodwill MP for the story on Robert’s wife writing to one of Robert’s constituents threatening to have him arrested because she found “perverted” hardcore pornography on Robert’s PC and was “utterly disgusted”. The constituent was, of course, entirely innocent and knew nothing about it, leaving the question as to who it was that downloaded “perverted” porn onto Robert’s PC, and for what purpose? Unresolved. Robert, of course, refused to comment, leaving readers to draw their own inevitable conclusion . . .

Video of the pornography found on Robert Goodwill’s PC and seen by his children has not been requested; on the basis that we probably could not show it.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The Benny Hill Memorial Prize for Utterly Uncompetent Basic Police Work.

GOLD :Scarborough Police, for not ordering a search of Jimmy Savile’s flat in Scarborough – thereby earning national press criticism – and earning further press criticism for failing to search the premises in Whitby (alleged to have been used by Jimmy Savile and others), which was fitted out with a “whipping post”.  Scarborough police can be seen in action here:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The Inspector Clouseau Memorial Prize for Failed Intimidation of the Press

GOLD : – Ex-Chair of the North Yorkshire Police Authority County Councillor Jane Kenyon, for abusing her position as Chair of the Police Authority by trying to have Tim Hicks framed for harassment and arrested by her favourite pet detective, apparently because she had appeared in Private Eye and Tim was investigating her expenses. Senior Detective Ventura [pseudonym] can be seen in action here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzxDlS6QY1s

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The T Dan Smith, John Poulson & Sir Bernard Kenyon Memorial Prize for Local Authority Corruption

GOLD :County Councillor Jane Kenyon (again), for double-dipping; not declaring her interests; appearing twice in Private Eye in half a year for separate acts of misconduct (thought to be a record); not declaring that she is the CFO of a bankrupt company; trying to have Tim Hicks arrested and mismanaging the Whitby Regatta Committee by turning it into a duplicated commercial company.

SILVER :Highly Commended:  NYCC Monitoring Officer Carole Dunn, for ignoring legitimate complaints against Councillors and pre-determining that they are entitled to be paid twice for their Broadband connections, -thereby obtaining a very well deserved mention in Private Eye for herself and the fifteen Councillors concerned- when in fact they obviously are not.  Please see here video of the standards committee investigation into double dipping: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1BxFlmb6S6E

BRONZE : – Jointly:  Councillor David Parsons, the former Leader of Leicestershire County Council now sacked, disbarred from the Conservative Party, forced to repay the money and under investigation by the Police for double-dipping shares the Award with the 15 double-dipping Councillors from Scarborough Borough Council and North Yorkshire County Council, who have so far escaped the same fate due to the machinations of the Monitoring Officers.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The David Parsons Prize for the Best  Written Comment NOT Received in 2012

GOLD :Councillor Joe Plant for his ‘full and frank statement’ to the newspapers justifying double dipping by himself and his fellow Councillors, which we are all still awaiting apparently because neither he nor the monitoring officers can think of any credible defence for publication.

SILVER : – Highly Commended:  Scarborough Borough Council, North Yorkshire County Council, North Yorkshire Police Authority, North Yorkshire Police and the Police and Crime Commissioner, who have all adopted the strategy – when faced with irrefutable evidence of misconduct – of refusing to respond to correspondence on the matter, thereby evading their duty to confront misconduct, rather than show honesty, integrity and leadership, and actually deal with the problem. This clip shows them all being briefed by Jane Kenyon:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The Jonathan Aitken Memorial Prize for the Best Broadcast Media ‘LIVE Interview

GOLD : –  SBC Leader Councillor Tom Fox, for being caught out lying on BBC Radio York by Tim Thorne.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Looking forward to 2013, Corruption Busters will be adopting a more focussed approach and will be continuing our exposure of the 15 double-dipping Councillors, which we expect to be an election issue at the County Council Elections in May 2013.

15_double_dippers

Nigel will be working on OPERATION EASTERN PARADISE an examination of the Chief Officers expenses and those of other Council employees, and Tim Thorne on further expenses investigations, locally and in Westminster. Tim Hicks will be monitoring the Monitoring Officers and following up on the Jimmy Savile cover-up.

3_wise_bobbies

Also coming in the New Year: even more serious allegations have emerged about the double-dippers and we will continue to press them to re-pay the estimated £15,000–£20,000 that they have received improperly, at a time when the Council is cutting back on services.

We hope you enjoyed the videos and wish our readers a happy and prosperous 2013.

Thanks for all your support and have a great New Year.

–    Corruption Busters

Share This Post

10 Responses to "Corruption Busters 2012 Round-Up"

  1. Brian Dodds  December 30, 2012 at 10:45 pm

    It will be very interesting to see what develops in 2013, none of these scandals are going to go away, I personally have spoken to quite a few local people about them and I will carry on doing so. Hopefully sooner or later old stormin Norman Murphy will get his teeth into some of it and really put the cat amongst the pigeons. To all the people involved with the Real Whitby project, may I wish you a very happy, healthy and prosperous New Year.

    Reply
  2. Jane Swales  December 30, 2012 at 10:57 pm

    ‘Bringing the Council into disrepute’ must be an open and shut case – if only there was a councillor with the, er, chutzpah to bring it. Can you see Storming Norman storm that one?

    Reply
  3. Ian Detute  December 31, 2012 at 1:09 am

    Real Whitby doing what the Whitby Gazette is scared to do. Carry on digging and good luck in 2013.

    Reply
  4. Tim Tubbs  December 31, 2012 at 6:15 pm

    I can’t say I’ve been too eager to engage with local Council politics in Scarborough/NYCC, after a dismal experience of London local authorities over 25 years 1982-2008 (GLC, ILEA, LBGC, Islington, Camden, Westminster under Shirley Porter etc – all very deeply depressing), but maybe it’s time I woke up and did something about these stories, which I had been vaguely aware of in the last year, and which confirm my worst fears and suspicions of our elected representatives. Breathtaking. It sounds as though you are to be congratulated on a courageous stand against petty apparatchiks and their dodgy doings. It also sounds as though we voters should take a more positive stance to combat corruption and shabby behaviour in local authorities. A New Year’s Resolution? And if half what is alleged in the press of Ms Jane Kenyon is true (and if it weren’t, I presume she would have sued or taken out contracts by now on those who alleged it), she should be dismissed from public service in very short order. Perhaps she and Dame Shirley Porter could compare notes? (No, I mustn’t mention Tesco in Scarborough, must I?) Meanwhile, keep up the good work. The public owes you a debt of thanks for your persistence.

    Reply
  5. Richard Ineson  January 3, 2013 at 6:10 pm

    Well done to our local Councils and Councillors, but I must say that I was disappointed to note that there didn’t seem to be a category for the biggest waste of public money. This prize could have been awarded, jointly to SBC and NYCC for their respective parts in the Irton tree fiasco – remember? Yes, that’s it, £300,000 to cut a tree down. The NYCC High(mysterious)Ways Department played a leading role in this spectacular rape of the public purse, but SBC managed to poke their nose in and make a bad job even worse. Another contender might have been the £415,000 already invested in the Whitby Park and (get taken for a)Ride scheme,with not much to show for this sizeable sum of public money except the ‘bollard which never rises’ but in this case, there is always next year, and the year after that, ad nauseum. Happily,the North Yorkshire Police Authority has been abolished, otherwise they might have been in contention for an award, remember the £28,400 shower and the £500,000 spent on flashy cars for senior police officers, in happier times? Happy New Year and Trebles all round, no, make them Quads, might as well go down with all guns blazing.

    Reply
    • sarraceniac  January 4, 2013 at 4:33 pm

      At the time I wondered why SBC/NYCC were so quick to agree to cut down this tree, Richard. After all, it had been there long before the guy who wanted it removed had (recently) moved in and he must have seen it, so why did he buy the house without first sorting this (to him) problem? Caveat emptor etc. There was a rumour at the time that he is a prominent member of his local Conservative Association and appears to be a cross dresser because I am informed he often wears an apron (nudge, nudge, wink, wink, know what I mean?)I did ask around and nobody would confirm or deny either of these rumours. But a casual friend of mine, who is actually well known for his honesty, did resign from the Filey Lodge of the Moonies around this time. He refused to say why.

      Reply
  6. Tom Brodrick  January 4, 2013 at 4:13 pm

    Welcome Tim Stubbs.
    Yes, what is so difficult about being a good stand up kind of person? Each and every one of the situations you will read about on Real-Whitby regards Councillors and Councils can be so easily resolved, most with just a simple apology.
    Whilst others an apology accompanied with the return of money that was taken unfairly, dishonestly, unknowingly or just downright greedily grabbed from the public purse without as much as a care in the world.

    Reply
  7. Richard Ineson  January 4, 2013 at 4:23 pm

    I agree with Tom Brodrick, most of these cases could be easily resolved with an acknowledgement that things have not been done as they should have been and an apology. The trouble is that these people are so arrogant and have been getting away with doing as they please for so long, that they cannot believe that they are doing anything wrong. Then we have certain Council employees who grease around these posturing windbags and make them believe in their own publicity. What a shower! (please don’t mention that shower again).

    Reply
  8. Richard Ineson  January 4, 2013 at 4:26 pm

    “Anyone who is spreading misinformation and sometimes lies needs to be brought to account”

    Tom Fox, Conservative Councillor and leader of Scarborough Borough Council, 6th June 2011.

    Reply
  9. Julian Armitage  January 9, 2013 at 1:20 pm

    Nigel Ward and all at “Corruption Busters” a difficult year for those whose dark arts have been exposed with a clarity of journalism I hope will carry through to 2013 and should by right of DEMECRATIC justice continue under one of the greatest ideals we hold true THE FREEDOM OF SPEECH and the ability to hold to account those we have elected…

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

whitby photography by glenn kilpatrick